Monday, April 11, 2011
The Ban of The Burqa
The other day in class when we were talking about feminism, the subject of the burqa came up. Recently in France, the burqa was banned and I came across this article today and I wanted to know what you thought? Do you think the burqa should be banned? Or do you think that all women should be able to express their beliefs freely?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I definitely think that women should be able to wear burqas or whatever other religious clothing or accessories that they want to. If they don't let women wear burqas, then they shouldn't let anyone wear any religious paraphernalia, including yarmulkes, tilakas, or crosses. Also, if these women feel that strongly about wearing their burqas, then they will keep doing it. This will end with a lot of trouble and problems for everyone.
ReplyDeleteI definitely think that women should be able to wear burqas or whatever other religious clothing or accessories that they want to. If they don't let women wear burqas, then they shouldn't let anyone wear any religious paraphernalia, including yarmulkes, tilakas, or crosses. Also, if these women feel that strongly about wearing their burqas, then they will keep doing it. This will end with a lot of trouble and problems for everyone.
ReplyDeleteThis article is extremely interesting but controversial at the same time. While I believe restricting Islamic women's rights to religious freedom is wrong, I also see the motivation behind the French parliament. I do not believe the purpose of these restrictions are meant to offend anyone but rather reinforce the safety of the French citizens. The main issue, as cited in this article, is the governments inability to determine a person's identity. To me this is a legitimate concern that was rightfully addressed. This issue also parallels our reading of Catherine Keller's novel, On the Mystery; specifically, her definition of the absolute and dissolute. The French government embodies a middle of the road approach similar to Keller's third way by permitting the use of Islamic head wraps that leave the face exposed. I think this is a fair compromise allowing Muslim women to express their religious beliefs while maintaining a safe environment.
ReplyDeleteI thought this was an interesting article on a highly controversial topic. In my opinion France’s ban on the burka is unacceptable. If women choose to wear the burka they should be allowed the right to do so; this is a form of religious persecution and stereotyping that is dangerous to anyone associated with Islam. Furthermore, many states in America are beginning to discuss similar legislation because of France’s actions; even though, it blatantly contradicts our constitutional rights. This irrational fear of all Muslims reminds me of a mob mentality that can be traced throughout history; persecution of other ethnic and religious groups always begins with this form of fear and distinction that separates them from the rest of society. I sincerely hope that other countries do not follow France’s example by enacting similar legislation.
ReplyDelete